Saturday, May 03, 2008

Is J2EE Disruptive



The answer to this question depends on the context, i.e. the market with respect to which we are asking it.


In his 1997 national best seller, The Innovator's Dilemma, the Harvard Business School professor Clayton M. Christensen coined the terms disruptive and sustaining technologies.


According to Christensen, most new technologies improve product performance. He calls such technologies sustaining technologies. In contrast, he identifies disruptive technologies to be those innovations that lead to worse product performance, at least in the near-term. He goes on to say that such initially less-performant technologies end up precipitating the leading firms' failure.


Christensen also notes that there are three reasons established companies do not invest in disruptive technologies. First, because disruptive technologies are simpler and cheaper, their use only provides low margins to begin with. Second, disruptive technologies are usually first commercialized in markets which the established firms consider to be insignificant. Third, established firms' most profitable customers cannot initially use such technologies. According to Christensen, a practiced discipline of "listening to customers and identifying new products that promise greater profitability and growth are rarely able to build a case for investing in disruptive technologies until it is too late."


Frankly, I am not sure I agree with this last point Christensen is making. I think listening to customers does not just mean listening to what it is they want. Often customers don't really know or think they know but are not sure if what they want jives with what's "there." The most important thing companies should listen for are "requirements" in a deep sense of that word, i.e. not what a customer wants from us but what their goals are, how they go about achieving it now and how they can go about achieving it in the future. This approach is quite different from just seeing what they want.


So, is J2EE an example of a disruptive technology in the Christensen sense of the word?


Well, in the enterprise market, J2EE has been proven to be the de facto platform because one can easily develop, deploy and maintain scalable applications in production environments. So, one may argue that in the enterprise market, J2EE may not be as disruptive as it once was. This may not be completely true. While some real innovations (such as JAX-RPC and Connectors) have emerged that are not just about "performance" in speed, some may still argue that these new innovations are simply about "performance" in integration. They may have a point.


However, that is not what I wanted to talk about. What I want to say is that Christensen's notions of disruptive and sustaining technologies really need to be applied and scoped with respect to particular markets.


So, let's ask the question again and scope it to the telecommunications market.


Is J2EE a disruptive technology in the telecommunications market?


Applying the Christensen analysis, we have no choice but to say that it is.


There are three classes of telecommunications applications where J2EE has a good fit as the emerging and disruptive middleware platform: OSS/BSS applications, service applications, service control function applications.


Who will take advantage of this opportunity will be offering the next-generation platform for convergence applications.

Once again for Lessig ! ! !


Institutional economists, such as Douglas North (Structure and Change in Economic History) have long argued that the protection of intellectual property was a necessary ingredient for the technology-driven economic growth of the post-industrial world.



North and others have been focusing on the importance of protecting private and intellectual property. Less attention has been given to the regulatory limits of such protection.


Over the years, copyright laws have expanded to include derivative work. It is not clear whether such expansion (to derivative work) is actually good for economic growth.


Once again, Stanford University Law professor Lawrence Lessig has written a wonderful book, this time on how new technologies affect our economic environment and our culture.


In this new book, Free Culture: How Big Media Uses Technology and the Law to Lock Down Culture and Control Creativity, Lessig examines the changes made to the copyright law and how those changes can stifle creativity and an open culture.


His writing is meant to be accessible to all, including those who do not have any training in law and its methods. He takes care to bring out some of the legal subtleties involved in a very lucid and accessible prose.


Lessig is one of the few legal scholars who have really thought hard about how new communications technologies are changing our world. Reading his works would be useful for all who play a role in the creation of such technologies.

A Bank is a Bank


Tehran, Iran (Nov. 2006)
Originally uploaded by M.Mortazavi
A bank is a bank no matter where it lives.

It does roughly the same thing everywhere.

Friday, March 21, 2008

Economizing and Strategizing


So, here I go, testing this Weblog system . . .


Oliver Williamson, the great contemporary economist, notes that there has been too much focus on triangles formed by supply-demand curves, i.e. on strategizing, and not enough attention on the larger rectangles, i.e. on economizing. A good place to read about this is in his book of essays on transaction cost economics, Mechanisms of Governance.



Saturday, March 15, 2008

Time and Transactions


Tehran Bazaar (August, 2006)
Originally uploaded by M.Mortazavi
In each minutes, a tremendously large number of transactions are carried out.

Only economies that improve the volume and value of such transactions per quanta of time and resources used will survive well in crisis.

Friday, March 14, 2008

Fear in the Minds

I find this paragraph from a Financial Times editorial published today telling a big story:

It would be pointless, foolish and wrong to try and fix the dollar at its current level. Markets are the best way to determine exchange rates, and on a trade-weighted basis it is far from clear that the dollar has overshot its fair value. But what intervention might do is slow the decline, by putting fear in the minds of momentum investors who are selling short on margin.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Transaction and Transportation


Tehran Metro (2005)
Originally uploaded by M.Mortazavi
Social stability comes about when society organizes itself to reduce all kinds of transaction costs.

In modern, large cities, transportation cost contributes, perhaps more than many other specific costs, to transaction costs.

Many transactions require people to be brought together or brought to specific locations.

Looking, Buying, Selling


Tehran Bazar (2005)
Originally uploaded by M.Mortazavi
Some look.

But Some will always buy.

And that will be enough.

Choices


Friday Bazar, Tehran (2005)
Originally uploaded by M.Mortazavi
He sells watches and waits.

The customer looks, and he looks at the customer, and wonders:

He is a real one, likely to buy, likely to make a choice.

He sells watches when he is free, and then goes back to one of his three or four other jobs.

Monday, September 17, 2007

From Mortgages to a Morass

This weekend Financial Times carried a picture of people queued to withdraw cash from Northern Rock. Several articles discussed the run on the bank. This morning, The Wall Street Journal reports that "British government will guarantee all existing deposits at troubled bank Northern Rock PLC, U.K. Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling."

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Diffusion of Financial Crisis among Economic Neighbors

In the last several months, as the credit crisis has rippled from the U.S. to Europe and back, I'm reminder of other historical examples:

Princes, abbots, bishops, even the Holy Roman Emperor debased the subsidiary coinage used in daily transactions (but not gold and silver coin of large denominations) by raising the denomination of existing monies, substituting baser for good metal, or reducing its weight, in order to extract more seignorage in the absence of effective tax systems and capital markets--this to prepare for the Thirty Years' War, which broke out in 1618. Debasement was limited at first to one's own territory. It was then found that one could do better by taking bad coins across the border of neighboring principalities and exchanging them for good with ignorant common people, bringing back the good coins and debasing them again. The territorial unit on which the original injury had been inflicted would debase its own coins in defense and turn to other neighbors to make good its losses and build its war chest. More and more mints were established. Debasement accelerated in hyper-fashion until a halt was called after the subsidiary coins became practically worthless, and children played with them in the street, much as recounted in Leo Tolstoy's short story, "Ivan the Fool."

Charles P. Kindleberger, Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crisis, 4th edition, p. 121, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York (2000)

Thursday, August 16, 2007

The Unraveling in Small Turns

Hal Weitzman reports from New York:

Countrywide, the beleaguered mortgage group, prompted an early plunge in stocks by saying it would have to draw on $11.5bn of credit and an official reports showed new homebuilding dropped to a 10-year low while building permits were at an 11-year low in July.

. . . “While Fed officials are proceeding as if the calamity has yet to occur, it would appear that some in the market believe the calamity is simply yet to be fully appreciated,” said analysts at Interactive Brokers.

. . . Nerves were not soothed by the Federal Reserve pumping more liquidity into the system on Thursday morning. The New York Fed announced an overnight repurchase agreement worth $12bn and a 14-day repurchase worth $5bn, while signalling that it expected to make similar repurchases on a more regular basis over the coming days.

. . . An hour before the opening bell, the Commerce Department released a gloomy report on US housing starts, showing that construction of new homes last month dropped to its lowest level in 10 years. The figures underlined the woes that have beset the homebuilding and mortgage sectors in recent weeks.